Blog › Sales and follow up

How to write a cold email with AI that gets replies

By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 5 min read

A plain way to use ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini to write short cold emails that sound like a person and get answers. Prompts included.

Short answer

How do I write a cold email with AI that gets replies?

To write a cold email with AI that gets replies, give it who the person is, one real reason you are writing, and what you sell in one plain line. Ask for under 75 words, no fancy openers, and one easy question at the end.

Then cut anything that sounds like a robot and send it from your own inbox. Short, specific and about them beats long and clever every time.

Steps

  1. Pick one person, not a list. Look up their title, company and what the company does. Check their LinkedIn and the company site for something real, like a new location, a job post, or a product line.
  2. Write your reason in one line. Why them, why now. "You are hiring two inside sales reps" is a reason. "I came across your company" is not.
  3. Write what you do in one line. Use the buyer's words. "We run cold calls for distributors" is clear. "We provide end to end revenue services for your growth" is not.
  4. Paste all three into a prompt. Use one of the prompts below in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
  5. Edit hard, then send. Cut the first sentence if it is a warm-up. Make sure every fact is true. Send it like a normal email, not a newsletter.

Prompts you can copy

The short cold email

Prompt. Paste it into Claude or any AI chat.
You are a sales rep writing a cold email to one person. Write like a real person typing fast, not like marketing.

Who they are: [name, title, company]
Why I am writing to them now: [one real, checked reason]
What I sell, in plain words: [one line]
What I want: [a 15 minute call / a yes or no / to send them something]

Write the email under 75 words. Start with them, not me. One idea only. End with one question they can answer in a few words.

Rules: no "I hope this finds you well", no "I wanted to reach out", no "just a short note". No buzzwords. No exclamation marks. Give me a subject line of 2 to 4 plain words, lower case.

Make my draft sound human

Prompt. Paste it into Claude or any AI chat.
Here is a cold email I wrote:
[paste your draft]

Make it shorter and plainer. Keep my facts. Remove anything that sounds like AI wrote it, like "I hope", "I wanted to", big buzzwords, or long lists. Keep it under 70 words. Show me what you cut and why in one line each.

Three openers to test

Prompt. Paste it into Claude or any AI chat.
I sell [what you sell] to [job title] at [type of company].

Here is what I know about this prospect: [facts you checked]

Write 3 different first lines for a cold email. One about their company news, one about a problem people in their role often have, one that is a direct question. Each under 20 words. No flattery.

What does a made-up example look like?

This is a made-up example.

Input: Mark, sales manager at a plumbing supply distributor with 6 branches. They posted two inside sales jobs last week. I run a team of cold callers who call contractors for distributors.

A good answer looks like this:

Subject: inside sales hires

Hi Mark, you are hiring two inside sales reps. While you hire, my team could call your contractor list for you, so the pipeline is warm when they start. We are senior callers in Canada and the U.S. Worth a 15 minute call next week to see if it fits?

It is 55 words, it is about Mark, and the ask is easy.

What tips help?

  • Check every fact the AI writes. If you did not give it a fact, it may make one up.
  • Ask for 3 versions and blend the best lines.
  • Read it on your phone. If it needs scrolling, it is too long.
  • Write the email you would answer yourself. If you would delete it, they will too.
  • Find better reasons to write by looking at LinkedIn for leads.

What should you not do?

  • Do not paste a big list and ask for hundreds of personal emails. You get a pile of emails that all sound the same.
  • Do not open with praise you did not mean, like "I was so impressed by your website".
  • Do not stack three asks. One question, at the end.
  • Do not attach PDFs to a first email. It looks like spam and spam filters agree.

FAQ

How long should a cold email be?

Short enough to read in 20 seconds on a phone. Aim for under 80 words. If you need more, you are probably saying two things.

Should the AI write the subject line too?

Yes, but keep it plain, 2 to 4 words, like you would write to a coworker. Avoid clickbait and all caps.

Is it OK to send cold emails written by AI?

Yes, as long as you check the facts and it is honest. The AI is a fast first draft. You are still the one sending it, so make sure it is true and sounds like you.

What do I do after the first cold email?

Plan a few follow ups that each bring something new. Our post on AI prompts to follow up on leads has prompts for that.

First posted . Last updated .

Read next

Want us to run this for you?

Book a call. We'll look at who you sell to and your offer, and tell you straight where to start.

Book a discovery call