Blog › Sales and follow up

Outbound team vs a broker: a better way for PE firms and search funds to find deals

By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 6 min read

Broker-run sales put a buyer up against five or more offers. Here is what brokers, bankers and in-house sourcing really cost, and when a calling team that reaches owners first is the better bet.

Short answer

Should a PE firm or search fund use a business broker or an outbound team to find acquisitions (outbound: reaching out to people first)?

Short answer: a broker works for the seller. Their job is to get the highest price, so they bring in as many buyers as they can. An outbound team works for you. It calls owners before they ever hire a broker, so you're the first buyer they talk to, often the only one. Brokers are still useful when you need a deal fast and want clean numbers. If you want more owner conversations and fewer bidding wars, add a calling team.

The problem with broker-run deals

When a broker or banker sells a company, they run an auction. That's good for the seller and hard on you.

  • You're one of many. In 2026, companies selling for $5M to $50M got about 5 offers on average. 87% got 3 or more offers, and a third got 10 or more (IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse, Q2 2026).
  • Sellers have the power. 76% of advisors on $5M to $50M deals called it a seller's market, and those sellers got about 100% of their asking price (IBBA Q2 2026).
  • Other private equity firms are bidding too. PE was the buyer in 47% of those deals (IBBA Q2 2026).
  • It's slow. A broker-run lower middle market sale takes about 11 to 12 months from start to close (IBBA Q2 2026).
  • More bidders usually means a higher price. Buyers and advisors commonly estimate that auctioned deals cost about a turn of EBITDA more than deals bought directly. That's an estimate, not a measured number, but the direction holds: more competition, higher entry price (Erasmus study of 1,592 deals). On a company with $2M of EBITDA, one turn is $2M.

What each option really costs

OptionWho it works forWhat it usually costs
Business broker (small sales)The sellerAbout 8% to 12% of the price, with a $10K to $25K minimum (Nav, Investors Club)
M&A advisor or banker ($5M to $50M)The seller$5K to $10K a month while they work, plus about 2.7% to 5.5% at close, depending on size (Firmex US M&A Fee Guide, DealRoom)
Buy-side advisorYouA monthly fee plus about 1% to 5% at close (DealRoom, Divestopedia)
In-house sourcing hireYouAbout $150K to $340K a year in pay for one associate or VP (Heidrick & Struggles 2024), plus data tools that often run $15K to $40K a year each (PrivSource)
Outbound calling teamYouA monthly fee, often with a smaller fee at close. Far less than a full-time hire.

Even when the seller pays the broker, you pay for it in the price.

Why an outbound team wins for a buyer

  1. You get there before the auction. Most owners sell to retire. 62% to 72% of sales from $500K to $50M were driven by retirement, and 60% to 90% of owners did less than a year of exit planning (IBBA Q2 2026). A friendly call reaches them while they're still thinking, before a broker is hired.
  2. You own the relationship. The owner gets to know you, not a middleman whose job is to push your price up. For a search fund, that's the whole edge: many owners care about their team and their legacy as much as the top dollar.
  3. More owner conversations. One associate can't dial all day and still build models. A calling team can work a few hundred owners a month and keep calling the ones who said "not yet".
  4. The phone stands out. A lot of sourcing shops only email and send LinkedIn messages (Tentt Finance). Owners of a $3M EBITDA business get plenty of email. A real person on the phone is rare.
  5. Your data stays yours. Every call is recorded, and every note and next step lives in your CRM (where every call, email and deal lives). An owner who says "call me in two years" is still on your list in two years, with the full history.
  6. It costs less than a hire. A calling team costs a fraction of one sourcing associate, and there's no 6 to 12 month ramp.

Where a broker is still the better choice

We'd rather you hear this from us:

  • Most owners aren't ready yet. A direct deal can take a year or two to come together. Search funds take about 20 months on average to buy a company, and only 58% ever do (Stanford GSB Search Fund Study 2026). If you need to close this quarter, a broker's list is faster.
  • No banker-made package. A direct owner won't hand you a polished deal book or clean financials. Your team does more of that work.
  • The owner might still hire a broker. Once a buyer shows real interest, some owners bring in an advisor to test the price. A "proprietary" deal can turn into a small auction.

Most funds do both: they take the good broker deals when they come and run a steady calling program so they aren't living on broker deal flow.

How a deal-sourcing calling program works

  1. Pick 2 to 3 industries. Narrow beats wide. A small industry in one region might only have 30 to 50 targets, so you work every one of them well.
  2. Build the list. Business lists, then the owner's name, a verified cell number and a check that they still run the company.
  3. Call, then follow up. Calls lead, with LinkedIn and short emails in between. The first call is about one thing: is the owner open to a conversation about the future of the business?
  4. Hand off a meeting, not a name. You get a booked meeting with an owner who agreed to talk, plus the call recording and notes.
  5. Keep the "not yets" warm. Every "maybe in a year" gets a date and a call on that date.

The bottom line

A broker sells you a deal everyone else has seen. A calling team finds owners before anyone else does. If proprietary deal flow matters to your fund, you need someone on the phone with owners every day. That's what we do: book a call and we'll walk you through how we'd run it for your industries.

private equitysearch funddeal sourcingproprietary dealsbusiness brokercold calling

First posted . Last updated .

Read next

Want us to run this for you?

Book a call. We'll look at who you sell to and your offer, and tell you straight where to start.

Book a discovery call