Both can work. An agency gets calls going faster and you can stop when you want. A hire builds skill inside your company, but takes time to hire, train and manage.
Last updated Nov 2026
| Cold calling agency | Hiring an SDR | |
|---|---|---|
| Time to first calls | Days. Most of our clients start in 2 to 5 days. | Weeks to months: write the job post, interview, hire, then train. |
| What you pay for | A monthly fee for the calling. | A salary, plus benefits, tools and a manager’s time. |
| Who manages it | The agency runs the callers and the list. | You, or someone on your team. |
| If it isn’t working | Change the script or stop at the end of the term. | Coach them, or go through letting someone go. |
| What stays with you | The meetings, recordings and notes, if the agency logs them in your tools. | The person, their skill and what they learn about your buyers. |
| Best when | You want to test calling before you commit, or need more volume now. | Calling already works for you and you want it in-house for years. |
It depends on how long you need it. An agency has no hiring cost and you can stop, while a hire costs a salary, benefits, tools and management time every month.
The honest test is cost per held meeting, not the monthly price. Run a short pilot (a test run before you commit), count the meetings that actually happen, and compare that to what a hire would cost you over the same months.
An agency. Most of our clients have calls going in 2 to 5 days, while hiring an SDR usually takes weeks before the first call (SDR: callers who book meetings).
A new hire also needs time to learn your buyers and your offer. An agency’s callers already know how to cold call (calling people who don’t know you yet), but still need to learn your product.
Published 2025 benchmarks put it in the hundreds. Belkins reports roughly 370 dials to book one meeting from cold calls.
Whoever makes the calls, plan for volume. Connect rates in 2025 were around 6.5% (Abstrakt) to 9.9% (Belkins) of dials. Our own numbers are on our cold calling benchmarks page.
When cold calling already books meetings for you and you want to own it for the long term.
A good in-house SDR builds knowledge that stays in your company. If you don’t know yet whether calling works for your buyers, test it first, then hire.
Ask to approve the script, hear recorded calls, and see every dial and meeting as it happens.
If an agency can’t show you those things, keep looking. More on this in what an outbound sales agency should do for you.
Book a short discovery call with Corey (discovery call: a first call where we learn about your business). Tell him how your team sells today. He’ll tell you straight, even if the answer is “do it yourself”.
Book a discovery call