Home › Sales help › Meetings
For appointment setters and SDRsAppointment setting: how to book meetings that are worth having
By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 4 min read
An appointment setter isn't paid for the calendar invite. They're paid for the meetings that happen and turn into something. Here's how to book more of those.
Short answer
How do I become a better appointment setter?
Qualify before you book: hear the problem, the timing and the decision maker in their words. Book the meeting live with two specific times, send the invite while they're on the phone, and give the meeting a clear reason. Confirm by phone the day before, rebook no-shows fast, and hand off with notes the closer can use in the first two minutes of the meeting.
What a good appointment actually is
A good appointment has four things:
- The right person. Someone who can buy, or who'll bring the person who can.
- A real problem, said out loud by them.
- A clear reason for the meeting that they agreed to.
- A time on their calendar, accepted, and confirmed the day before.
Miss any one and the meeting either doesn't happen or goes nowhere.
Qualify on the call
You don't need a full discovery. You need just enough to know the meeting is worth having. Ask a few short questions and listen.
Problem: "How are you handling [problem] right now?" Impact: "What's that costing you, time or money?" Timing: "Is fixing that on the list for this quarter, or later?" Decision: "Who else would want a say in something like this?"
If you hear a real problem and some urgency, book it. If you don't, don't force it. Put them in your follow-up and try again when something changes.
Know your team's qualifying rules and stick to them. If you're not sure, ask your closer: "What makes a meeting worth your time?" See the SDR to AE handoff.
Book it live
The meeting isn't booked until it's on their calendar.
"Based on what you said, it's worth 20 minutes with [Closer], who works with [type of company] on exactly this. I can do tomorrow at 10 or Thursday at 2, your time. Which is better?" [They pick] "Great. I'm sending the invite now from my email. Can you see it? Can you hit accept so it's locked in on your side too?"
Two specific times. The soonest first. Send the invite while they're still on the line. See how to ask for the meeting.
Make the invite useful
- Title: the reason, not "Intro call." For example: "[Company] x [Their Company]: covering calls while new reps ramp (20 min)"
- Description: two lines on what you'll cover, who'll be there, the link and your number.
- Who's invited: the closer and anyone the prospect said should be there.
Confirm the day before
"Hi [Name], it's [You] from [Company]. Quick one: we're on for tomorrow at 10 with [Closer] about [reason]. Still good?"
If they need to move it, move it on the spot. A reschedule is a meeting that's still alive. See how to cut no-shows.
Hand off like a pro
The closer should know enough to skip the small talk. Before the meeting, send notes:
Who: [Name], [Title], [Company] ([size, location]) Why now: [Dated reason or what they said] Problem: [In their words, quoted if possible] Current: [How they handle it today / who they use] Timing: [When they want it fixed] Others: [Who else is involved in deciding] Watch: [Anything to be careful about] Recording/notes: [link]
Inbound leads: speed wins
If you set appointments from inbound leads (form fills, demo requests), speed is everything. Call within minutes, not hours. The longer you wait, the colder they get. See speed to lead.
Track the numbers that matter
| Number | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Conversations per day | Your real activity |
| Meetings booked per conversation | How well you ask |
| Booked to held | How well you qualify and confirm |
| Held meetings that move forward | Whether you're booking the right people |
The last one is the one your closer cares about most.
What not to do
- Don't book to hit a number. Bad meetings cost the closer time and cost you trust.
- Don't oversell the meeting. If you promise a demo and they get a sales pitch, they won't show next time.
- Don't hand off with "they're interested." Give the closer real notes.
- Don't let a no-show sit. Rebook it within the hour.
Want help with this?
We book meetings for clients every week, and a no-show is ours to rebook. If you want a second set of eyes on how you're setting, book a call with Corey.
Coaching with Corey
One-on-one consulting. You do the work and Corey shows you every step: who to go after, what to say, the outreach, and an honest audit of what is working.
Sales Training
Your reps know what to say, on the calls they already make. See Fractional Services
More meetings, run by us
Real callers and LinkedIn outreach on your buyers, or a push of 2 months or less. See Sales Sprints
FAQ
What makes a good appointment setter?
Someone who books meetings that actually happen and turn into opportunities: they qualify on the call, book live, confirm the day before and hand off good notes.
How do I qualify an appointment on a cold call?
Ask a few short questions about the problem, its impact, the timing and who else decides. If you hear a real problem and some urgency, book it.
Should I book appointments as soon as possible?
Yes, close is better. Within 48 hours when you can, and inside the same week when you can't. Long gaps lead to more no-shows.
What should an appointment setter send the closer?
A short handoff note: who, why now, the problem in their words, what they use today, timing, who else is involved, and a link to the call recording or notes.
Want a second set of eyes on this?
Book a short call with Corey. Tell him what you sell, who you sell to and where you are stuck. He’ll tell you straight what he’d fix first.
Book a call