Home › Sales help › Follow-up
For SDRs, BDRs and AEs"Call me next quarter": what to do with not-now leads
By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 4 min read
"Not now" is one of the most useful things a prospect can tell you. It's not a no. It's a date, if you ask the right question. Most reps write it down and never call back. That's a lot of meetings left on the table.
Short answer
What should I do when a prospect says "not now"?
Ask what will be different later, so you get a real reason and a real date. Write both in your CRM with a task to follow up a little before that date. In between, stay in front of them lightly with something useful every few weeks, not "just checking in." When you call back, open by reminding them of what they told you. Most of your future meetings are sitting in this list.
"Not now" isn't a no
You can do everything right and still catch someone in the wrong season. They're mid-project, closing the year, waiting on budget, hiring someone first. "Not now" usually means exactly that.
The job is to be there when "now" comes.
Step 1: Get the real reason
Don't just say "OK, I'll call you next quarter." Ask what will change.
"Totally fair. Just so I call you back at the right time, what's going to be different next quarter?"
Good answers sound like:
- "We're finishing our CRM migration in February."
- "Budget for next year gets approved in January."
- "We're hiring a sales manager first."
- "Our contract with [vendor] is up in June."
Each one is a date and a reason to call.
Step 2: Get a real date
"So if I check back in early February, after the migration, is that about right? Should I call you, or is email better?"
Some people will even agree to a tentative meeting: "Want to pencil in 20 minutes for the second week of February? Easy to move if it shifts."
Step 3: Write it down properly
In your CRM, on the lead:
- What they said, in their words
- The reason for the timing
- The date to follow up (a week or two before their date)
- The best channel to reach them
- A task with a reminder
If it's not in the CRM with a date, it doesn't exist.
Step 4: Stay in front of them, lightly
Between now and the follow-up date, don't disappear. But don't pester either. One useful touch every three to four weeks:
- A short note when something relevant happens in their industry
- A useful idea related to their problem
- A LinkedIn comment on something they posted, if you have something real to say
- A congratulations if they announce news
Subject: thought of you Hi [Name], Saw [relevant thing]. Made me think of what you said about [their situation]. No need to reply. I'll check back in February like we said. [You]
"No need to reply" takes the pressure off. Ironically, it often gets replies.
Step 5: Call back with their words
When the date comes, open by reminding them what they told you. It shows you listened, and it makes the call warm.
"Hi [Name], it's [You] with [Company]. Back in October you said to call after the CRM migration wrapped up in February. I figured that's about now. How did it go?"
Then pick up the conversation where you left off. If the timing still isn't right, ask the same question again: "What's going to be different?"
Step 6: Watch for early signals
Sometimes "now" comes early. Watch for:
- A new job post related to your problem
- A new leader in the seat
- News about the project they were waiting on
- Them engaging with your posts or emails
If you see one, reach out early with that reason. See how to find buying signals.
Build the list into your week
Your not-now list is pipeline. Treat it that way:
- Weekly: work every follow-up task due this week. These go at the top of your call list.
- Monthly: skim the whole list for new signals.
- Quarterly: look at how many not-now leads turned into meetings. It's usually more than people expect.
When you're behind on quota, this list is one of the first places to look.
What not to do
- Don't accept "next quarter" without a reason. Ask what will change.
- Don't send "just checking in." Send something useful, or nothing.
- Don't call before the date unless something changed.
- Don't cold-open someone who told you "not now." Always remind them of the last conversation.
Want help with this?
The phone opens the door, and then we stay in front of everyone we talk to on LinkedIn and email until their timing turns. If you want help building that into your own follow-up, book a call with Corey.
Coaching with Corey
One-on-one consulting. You do the work and Corey shows you every step: who to go after, what to say, the outreach, and an honest audit of what is working.
Sales Training
Your reps know what to say, on the calls they already make. See Fractional Services
More meetings, run by us
Real callers and LinkedIn outreach on your buyers, or a push of 2 months or less. See Sales Sprints
FAQ
What does it mean when a prospect says "not now"?
Usually that the timing is wrong, not the fit. Ask what will be different later to get a real reason and a date.
How do I follow up when a prospect says "call me next quarter"?
Ask what will change, agree on a date, log both in your CRM with a task, stay in front of them lightly in between, and call back with their own words.
How often should I contact a "not now" lead?
One useful touch every three to four weeks, plus a call around the date they gave you. Reach out sooner only if a new buying signal shows up.
Should I book a meeting months in advance for a "not now" lead?
You can offer a tentative one that's easy to move. Some people like having it on the calendar. Either way, set a follow-up task for a week or two before.
Want a second set of eyes on this?
Book a short call with Corey. Tell him what you sell, who you sell to and where you are stuck. He’ll tell you straight what he’d fix first.
Book a call