Home › Sales help › Email and LinkedIn

For SDRs, BDRs and AEs

How to book meetings from cold email

By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 4 min read

Cold email isn't dead. Lazy cold email is. If your emails could go to anyone, people treat them like they went to everyone. Here's how to write ones that get a reply and turn that reply into a meeting.

Short answer

How do I book meetings from cold email?

Send fewer, better emails to people who fit. Open with a line that proves you looked at them (their role, company or news), name one problem in their words, and end with one easy question, not a calendar link. Keep it to three to five short lines. Follow up three or four times with a new reason each time, then call. When someone replies with interest, offer two specific times and send the invite right away.

Here's why most cold emails get ignored

They're about the sender. "We're a leading provider of..." "I wanted to introduce..." "Do you have 15 minutes for a quick call?" Nothing in them is about the reader.

For email, I use Samantha McKenna's "Show Me You Know Me" approach. The first line proves you actually looked at them: something specific about their role, their company or their news. If you could swap in someone else's name and the email still made sense, it's not ready.

The shape of a cold email that books

Cold email structure
Subject: 2-4 words, lowercase is fine, about them

Line 1: Something specific about them (proves you looked)
Line 2: The problem that usually comes with that, in their words
Line 3: One line on how you help (optional)
Line 4: One easy question

[Your name]
[Company] | [website]

Three to five short lines. No attachments. No images. One link at most, your website in the signature so they can check you out.

Three templates

The trigger email

Trigger email
Subject: new sdr hires

Hi [Name],

Saw [Company] is hiring three SDRs. When teams add reps that fast, the first month usually goes to building lists instead of making calls.

Is that something you're planning for, or already sorted?

[You]

The peer email

Peer email
Subject: recruiters on sales calls

Hi [Name],

Most staffing owners I talk to say their recruiters end up making the sales calls, and neither job gets done well.

Is that happening at [Company] too?

[You]

The "who owns this" email

Who owns this
Subject: right person?

Hi [Name],

I help [type of company] with [problem]. Not sure if that sits with you or someone else on the team.

Who'd be the right person to talk to?

[You]

Ask a question, not for a meeting

Asking for 30 minutes in the first email is a big ask from a stranger. Asking a question they can answer in one line is a small one. Get the reply first. Then book the meeting.

When they reply with interest:

Turning a reply into a meeting
"Makes sense. Easier to walk through live. I can do Thursday at 10 or Friday at 2, your time. Which works? I'll send the invite."

Offer two times, send the invite as soon as they pick one, and confirm the day before. See how to ask for the meeting and how to cut no-shows.

Follow up with a new reason

Most replies come from follow-ups, not the first email. Send three or four, a few days apart, each with something new:

  1. Follow-up 1 (day 3): a useful idea or example in two lines.
  2. Follow-up 2 (day 7): a different problem you solve, or ask who owns it.
  3. Follow-up 3 (day 12): the close-out: "Should I close this out, or check back later?"

And call. An email followed by a call that mentions it ("I sent you a note on Tuesday about your SDR hires") gets a much warmer pickup. See a follow-up cadence that books meetings.

Research before you write

The first line is only as good as your research. Two to five minutes per person: their LinkedIn, their company's news and job posts, and anything in your CRM. See how to research a prospect in five minutes.

Make sure it lands

A great email in the spam folder does nothing. If your reply rates suddenly drop, check deliverability before you rewrite anything. See why cold emails go to spam and how to fix it.

Track the right numbers

Number What it tells you
Bounce rate Your list quality
Reply rate Whether your message and targeting work
Positive reply rate Whether you're reaching people with the problem
Meetings from replies Whether your ask works

Open rates are less reliable than they used to be because of privacy features in email apps. Judge emails by replies and meetings.

What not to do

  • Don't write about yourself first.
  • Don't send a calendar link to a stranger.
  • Don't use "just following up" or "bumping this."
  • Don't send a template that could go to anyone.
  • Don't send to an unverified list. Bounces hurt every email you send after.

Want help with this?

Every message we send has to make sense for that one person. If your emails aren't booking, book a call and we'll look at a few of them with you.

Coaching with Corey

One-on-one consulting. You do the work and Corey shows you every step: who to go after, what to say, the outreach, and an honest audit of what is working.

Sales Training

Your reps know what to say, on the calls they already make. See Fractional Services

More meetings, run by us

Real callers and LinkedIn outreach on your buyers, or a push of 2 months or less. See Sales Sprints

FAQ

How long should a cold email be?

Three to five short lines. Short enough to read on a phone without scrolling.

Should I put a calendar link in a cold email?

Not in the first email. Ask a question they can answer in one line. Once they reply with interest, offer two specific times or share a link.

How many follow-ups should I send after a cold email?

Three or four, a few days apart, each with a new reason. Pair them with calls if you have the number.

What's a good cold email reply rate?

It varies widely by market and list. Track your own reply rate and positive reply rate, and improve your targeting and first line before adding volume.

Want a second set of eyes on this?

Book a short call with Corey. Tell him what you sell, who you sell to and where you are stuck. He’ll tell you straight what he’d fix first.

Book a call