Home › Sales help › Email and LinkedIn

For SDRs, BDRs and AEs

Cold emails going to spam? How to fix deliverability

By Corey Leon, founder of Coda · · 4 min read

If your reply rate suddenly drops, don't rewrite your emails yet. They may not be landing at all. Deliverability is the boring part of cold email, and it decides whether anything else matters.

Short answer

Why are my cold emails going to spam?

Usually a mix of missing email authentication (SPF, DKIM and DMARC), sending to unverified lists that bounce, sending too many emails too fast from one mailbox, and emails that look like marketing (lots of links, images, tracking and salesy words). Fix authentication first, verify every address, keep volume per mailbox modest and steady, write short plain-text emails, and make it easy to opt out.

Signs you have a deliverability problem

  • Reply rate drops suddenly, with no change to your emails or list
  • More bounces than usual
  • Test emails to your own personal accounts land in spam or promotions
  • Replies say "found this in my spam folder"

If you see these, stop adding volume. More sends make it worse.

Step 1: Authenticate your domain

This is the first thing mailbox providers check. If you're not technical, ask whoever manages your email or IT to confirm all three are set up:

Record What it does
SPF Lists which servers are allowed to send email for your domain
DKIM Adds a signature that proves the email wasn't changed and came from you
DMARC Tells providers what to do with email that fails SPF or DKIM, and sends you reports

Since 2024, Google and Yahoo have required bulk senders to have these in place, along with easy unsubscribe and low spam complaint rates. Even if you're not a bulk sender, it's the baseline now.

Step 2: Consider a separate sending domain

Many teams send cold email from a separate domain (for example, a variation of the main one) so cold outreach doesn't put the main company domain at risk. If you do this:

  • Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC on it too.
  • Point the domain's website at your real site, so it looks legitimate.
  • Warm it up slowly before sending cold email (see below).

Talk to your manager or IT before setting this up. It's a company decision.

Step 3: Clean the list

Bounces tell providers you're sending to people who didn't ask for it. Keep them very low.

  • Verify every email address before you send.
  • Be careful with "catch-all" domains. They accept everything, so you can't verify the address.
  • Remove hard bounces right away. Never send to them again.
  • Don't send to role addresses like info@ or sales@ for cold outreach.

See how to fix a bad lead list.

Step 4: Watch your volume

Sending a lot of email from a brand-new mailbox looks like spam.

  • Warm up new mailboxes. Start with a small number of real emails a day and increase slowly over a few weeks.
  • Keep daily volume per mailbox modest. Spreading sends across a few mailboxes is safer than blasting from one.
  • Send steadily. Same rough volume every working day, not 500 on Monday and none on Tuesday.
  • Space sends out rather than sending everything at once.

Step 5: Write like a person

Emails that look like marketing get treated like marketing.

  • Plain text. No images, no fancy HTML templates.
  • One link at most, or none in the first email. Your website in the signature is fine.
  • No attachments in cold email.
  • Short. Three to five lines. See booking meetings from cold email.
  • Avoid spammy phrasing: ALL CAPS, lots of exclamation marks, "free," "guarantee," "act now."
  • Personal. Emails that only make sense for one person get more replies, and replies help your reputation.

Step 6: Consider turning off tracking

Open and click tracking adds hidden images and rewritten links. Many senders find turning them off helps deliverability, and open rates aren't very reliable anymore anyway. Judge by replies.

Step 7: Make it easy to say no

  • Include a simple way to opt out, like "If this isn't relevant, just let me know and I won't follow up."
  • Honor every opt-out right away.
  • Follow the email laws that apply where you and your buyers are. In the US that's CAN-SPAM, and Canada has CASL, which is stricter. If you're not sure what applies, ask your manager or legal team.

Step 8: Monitor it

  • Google Postmaster Tools shows your domain's reputation and spam rate with Gmail.
  • Send test emails to a few personal accounts on different providers now and then.
  • Watch bounce rate and reply rate weekly. See SDR metrics.

If you're already in spam

  1. Pause cold sends from the affected mailbox.
  2. Fix authentication and clean the list.
  3. Send only to warm contacts (people who've replied before) for a while.
  4. Restart cold email at low volume and build up slowly.

Don't rely on email alone

Even with perfect deliverability, some buyers don't read cold email. Pair it with calls and LinkedIn. See a follow-up cadence that books meetings.

Want help with this?

If you want a second set of eyes on your outbound setup, from the list to the message, book a call with Corey.

Coaching with Corey

One-on-one consulting. You do the work and Corey shows you every step: who to go after, what to say, the outreach, and an honest audit of what is working.

Sales Training

Your reps know what to say, on the calls they already make. See Fractional Services

More meetings, run by us

Real callers and LinkedIn outreach on your buyers, or a push of 2 months or less. See Sales Sprints

FAQ

Why do my cold emails go to spam?

Usually missing SPF, DKIM or DMARC, too many bounces, too much volume from one mailbox, or emails that look like marketing (links, images, tracking, salesy words).

What are SPF, DKIM and DMARC?

Email authentication records. SPF lists who can send for your domain, DKIM signs your emails to prove they're genuine, and DMARC tells providers what to do with emails that fail and sends you reports.

How many cold emails can I send per day?

Keep volume per mailbox modest and steady, warm up new mailboxes slowly, and spread sends across a few mailboxes rather than one. Exact limits depend on your provider.

Should I use a separate domain for cold email?

Many teams do, to protect the main company domain. Set up authentication on it, point it at your real website and warm it up. Make that decision with your manager or IT.

Want a second set of eyes on this?

Book a short call with Corey. Tell him what you sell, who you sell to and where you are stuck. He’ll tell you straight what he’d fix first.

Book a call